The Elms Renovation: History Preserved & Secrets Uncovered

Capturing the essence of the quintessential New England charm, The Elms Restaurant and Inn has become a beloved landmark on Main Street. The Elms opened its doors in 1799, operating as a quaint New England restaurant and inn until closing just two years ago. For long-time Ridgefielders, The Elms is extraordinary history, but to owners, the Scala family, The Elms is home.

The Scala family purchased the property in 1951, taking over the restaurant and inn business. Ridgefield resident, Steve Scala and his brothers Ed and Bill grew up in the colonial front house, built in 1740, working for the family business. In 1996, the family leased the restaurant to Brendan Walsh, who operated it until 2010.

From the street, eager eyes sneak peeks at the construction, yet, they must wait to see the history that is preserved behind the doors. Perhaps what makes The Elms project so special is that the old framework of the house remains intact, so in order to make new changes, they must work around some of the 1700 architecture and framing.   

Old world charm is evident in the original structural elements including the old barrel ceilings, the chimneys, handcrafted 40 ft. chestnut beams, and the chestnut framing. With the chestnut framing still in place, the layout of the rooms will remain the same.

For centuries, passersby have marveled at the historic beauty of The Elms, but few know about the antique qualities that lie underground. In the basement, the old kitchen and a colonial stone beehive oven remain. Around the corner is another stone structure with a hole that opens into a small igloo shaped space. This once served as a freezer, storing salted meats during The Elms’ early years. Interestingly, the basement used to have windows as well. Cement walling was recently installed, covering the windows and what used to be a dirt floor.

Historical artifacts buried deep within the old building are reminiscent of old legends and days gone by. While taking down the old walls in the main building a lady’s shoe that dates back to the 1800’s was discovered. Scala explains that women would hide one shoe in the wall to kick out the evil spirits and in doing so, protect the house and its inhabitants.

The Scala family’s appreciation for their home’s historic qualities is genuine, which gives solace to the community that the project is in good hands. “Being a part of taking it apart and putting it back together is a really important,” says Scala.

As old structures come down and new ones go up, like the Scala family, Ridgefield will remember the history embedded in this favorite Main Street property.